ToGather
Living Library · Published by ToGather · togatherproject.eu
ToGather/Living Library/Books/The Homo Faber Trilogy
Books · Governance, Culture & Vision, Belonging, Conflict

The Homo Faber Trilogy

An entry in the ToGather Living Library · researched and curated by Sharon Avraham · togatherproject.eu

Richard Sennett's three-book project on craftsmanship, cooperation, and the open city. The Craftsman (2008), Together (2012), and Building and Dwelling (2018) read together as one extended argument about the skills people need to live together.

Originated
2008-2018
Developed by
Richard Sennett
Themes
GovernanceCulture & VisionBelongingConflict

On this page
  1. What the trilogy is, and what it argues
  2. The author and the lineage he writes from
  3. The structure of the trilogy
  4. Core arguments, in Sennett's own words
  5. Communities and movements drawing on this trilogy
  6. The contemporary worker-cooperative movement (international)
  7. Theatrum Mundi (international, founded 2009)
  8. LSE Cities and the broader urban-design conversation (international)
  9. The contemporary "slow craft" and maker-movement networks (distributed)
  10. Workshop-tradition intentional communities (international, dispersed)
  11. How to read this trilogy
  12. Living examples and entry points for community builders
  13. Living examples
  14. Adjacent and inspired applications
  15. Entry points
  16. One caution
  17. Where it has been critiqued
  18. More resources
  19. Canonical primary sources
  20. Comparative books
  21. Theoretical lineage
  22. Companion frameworks
  23. From the ToGather archive

What the trilogy is, and what it argues

The Homo Faber trilogy is Richard Sennett's three-book project published by Yale University Press between 2008 and 2018, comprising The Craftsman (2008), Together: The Rituals, Pleasures, and Politics of Cooperation (2012), and Building and Dwelling: Ethics for the City (2018). The Latin phrase Homo Faber (literally "man the maker," in contrast to Homo Sapiens, "man the knower") names Sennett's central category. The argument is that the human capacity to make things and to live together is itself a craft, requiring time, material engagement, repetition, and the cooperative practices that workshops and cities have historically supported.

Each book holds a distinct argument that the others build on. The Craftsman argues that the desire to do work well for its own sake is a deep human motivation that modern labor systems have eroded, with consequences for what we can build and for who we become through building. The book traces craftsmanship across history (Roman brickmakers, Renaissance goldsmiths, Enlightenment printers, contemporary programmers and doctors) and identifies the material conditions that let craft flourish: a workshop space, an apprentice-master relationship, the time to repeat a task ten thousand times, an acceptance that mastery is provisional and that small mistakes are how the craft teaches.

Together extends the craftsmanship argument into the relational domain. Cooperation, Sennett argues, is itself a craft. The book distinguishes between dialectical cooperation (the verbal exchange of opposing views toward synthesis, derived from Plato through Hegel and Marx) and dialogic cooperation (mutual exchange for its own sake, derived from Mikhail Bakhtin and Robert Owen). Dialectical cooperation aims at agreement; dialogic cooperation aims at sustained relationship across persistent difference. Modern political life is heavily dialectical and increasingly bad at the dialogic. The book proposes that the rituals, pleasures, and politics of cooperation can be taught, practiced, and rebuilt where they have eroded.

Building and Dwelling extends the cooperation argument into urban form. Sennett distinguishes between the ville (the physical city: streets, buildings, infrastructure, land-use plans) and the cité (the lived city: how people relate, how strangers cross paths, how neighborhoods feel). Modern urban planning has progressively over-determined the ville at the expense of the cité, producing what Sennett calls "closed" cities (designed for legibility, separation, and control) instead of "open" cities (designed for permeability, encounter, and the productive friction of difference). The book proposes design principles for the open city: porous boundaries between zones, modest markers that orient without commanding, evolved-in time, and a tolerance for the incomplete.

The trilogy is for academic sociologists, urban planners, community builders, philosophers of work, and anyone trying to understand why modern life has become so difficult to share with others across difference. The writing is accessible but dense. Sennett moves between historical case study, contemporary fieldwork, and theoretical argument; the books reward slow reading. Bibliographic details: The Craftsman (Yale University Press, 2008, 326 pages, ISBN 978-0-300-11909-1); Together (Yale University Press, 2012, 323 pages, ISBN 978-0-300-18828-8); Building and Dwelling (Farrar, Straus and Giroux US / Allen Lane UK, 2018, 343 pages, ISBN 978-0-374-20033-6).

FROM THE FIELD

From the field. This trilogy sits at the intellectual foundation of the ToGather project. Sharon Avraham's first published Substack post, The Invisible Architecture: Why We Gather, names Sennett's Together and adrienne maree brown's Emergent Strategy as the two books that shaped his decision to start traveling to eco-villages, kibbutzim, and community-based projects around the world for the fifteen years of field research that became ToGather. The Sennett-brown pairing is the closest thing ToGather has to a canonical reading list. The archive's recurring interest in dialogic conversation (Tamera Forum, Way of Council), in craft as community practice (the build days at Feÿtopia, the brickmaking at Auroville), and in urban-rural permeability (the question of how village patterns travel back to cities, which Poli names at Feÿtopia) all run through ground Sennett laid.

The author and the lineage he writes from

Richard Sennett (born January 1, 1943, in Chicago) is the Centennial Professor of Sociology at the London School of Economics and former University Professor of the Humanities at New York University. He grew up in the Cabrini-Green public housing project in Chicago, in a Russian-Jewish émigré family. He trained from childhood as a cellist with hopes of a concert career; a hand injury followed by a botched surgery in his early twenties ended the music. Sennett has said that the disciplined attention he developed in music studies has stayed with him through every book he has written, and that craftsmanship is in part his attempt to describe what was lost when the music ended.

Sennett did graduate work in sociology at Harvard, where he studied with David Riesman (author of The Lonely Crowd) and worked alongside Erik Erikson and Hannah Arendt. His early books (The Uses of Disorder, 1970; The Fall of Public Man, 1976) established him as a public intellectual concerned with how modern life eroded the social conditions for civic life. The Hidden Injuries of Class (1972, with Jonathan Cobb) remains a touchstone in working-class studies. The Corrosion of Character (1998) and Respect in a World of Inequality (2003) extended the work into the conditions of post-industrial labor. The Homo Faber trilogy is the constructive turn after several decades of diagnostic work: Sennett spent the first half of his career describing what was breaking, and the second half describing the skills people would need to rebuild.

The intellectual lineage Sennett writes from is unusual for an American sociologist. He draws heavily on Mikhail Bakhtin (the Russian literary theorist whose concept of "dialogic" structures the central argument of Together), on Hannah Arendt (the political theorist whose distinction between labor and work underlies The Craftsman), on the European workshop tradition (William Morris, John Ruskin, the Bauhaus, the Italian guild tradition Sennett studied in fieldwork in Bologna), and on the Pragmatist tradition (especially John Dewey and Charles Sanders Peirce). The trilogy is less in conversation with French theory or with American liberalism than with the European democratic-socialist and workshop-cooperative tradition that runs from Robert Owen through Karl Polanyi to the contemporary Italian and Spanish cooperative movements.

Sennett has been married to the urban sociologist Saskia Sassen since 1987. Sassen's The Global City (1991) is the canonical text on how New York, London, and Tokyo became hubs of the global financial system. The two have collaborated on the Theatrum Mundi project (a research-and-practice initiative on cities, sound, and urban performance) and on critique of contemporary urbanism. Sennett founded the New York Institute for the Humanities, served as president of the American Council on Work, and has consulted on urban design projects in cities including Quito, Medellín, and Shanghai. He has been a Senior Fellow at the Center on Capitalism and Society at Columbia University since the early 2010s. The Homo Faber trilogy is his most-read project among community builders, urban designers, and the broader regenerative-organization conversation.

Reception of the trilogy has been wide. The Craftsman won the Spinoza Prize in 2010 and was translated into more than twenty languages. Together was widely reviewed and is a standard reference in the cooperation-studies and dialogic-practice literature. Building and Dwelling has been particularly influential in urban-planning and architecture circles, including at the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, the London School of Economics Cities programme, and the New York Institute of Technology's planning programs. Sennett continues to write and teach in his ninth decade; recent work has turned toward the climate question and the question of what cities will need to look like to survive the transition.

The structure of the trilogy

The trilogy is best read as one extended argument across three books. Each book stands alone, but the cumulative reading is what produces the picture Sennett is drawing.

The Homo Faber Trilogy: Three Scales of Making Three vertical panels showing the three books of the trilogy as three scales of making: The Craftsman 2008 at the scale of one person learning a skill, Together 2012 at the scale of two or more people cooperating, Building and Dwelling 2018 at the scale of the city. Connecting arrows show how each book extends the prior argument. RICHARD SENNETT · HOMO FABER TRILOGY · 2008-2018 BOOK 1 The Craftsman 2008 · Yale UP The scale of one person learning to do something well key concepts rote · problem-finding problem-solving workshop · apprentice ten thousand hours material consciousness BOOK 2 Together 2012 · Yale UP The scale of two or more people cooperating key concepts dialogic vs dialectical informal · formal · ceremonial ritual exchange subjunctive mood Bakhtin · Owen cooperation as a craft BOOK 3 Building and Dwelling 2018 · FSG / Allen Lane The scale of the city key concepts ville vs cité open vs closed city porous boundaries incomplete form Jane Jacobs · Mumford design for difference three scales of the same argument: the skills people need to live together
The three books move from the scale of one person learning a skill, to the scale of two or more people cooperating, to the scale of the city. Each book extends and applies the argument of the prior one.

The Craftsman is organized in three parts. Part One ("Craftsmen") moves through history (the Roman brick, the Renaissance goldsmith, the printing press) to identify what craftsmanship is. Part Two ("Craft") moves into the cognitive and material conditions of skilled work: the hand, the tool, resistance and ambiguity. Part Three ("Craftsmanship") moves into the political and ethical implications: motivation, ability, the relationship between craft and citizenship.

Together is also in three parts, each corresponding to a stage of cooperation. Part One ("Cooperation Shaped") moves through the historical conditions under which cooperation has been organized: from medieval workshops to nineteenth-century cooperative experiments (Robert Owen at New Lanark, the Bauhaus, the Italian guild revival). Part Two ("Cooperation Weakened") diagnoses the conditions that have eroded cooperation under modern capitalism. Part Three ("Cooperation Strengthened") proposes practices and design choices that rebuild cooperative capacity, including the famous discussion of dialogic versus dialectical exchange.

Building and Dwelling moves in two large arcs. The first arc traces the historical break between the ville (the physical city as planned object) and the cité (the city as lived experience), through case studies that include nineteenth-century Paris under Haussmann, twentieth-century Brasília under Costa and Niemeyer, and the contemporary planned cities of Asia. The second arc proposes design principles for an "open city" that closes the ville-cité gap: porous boundaries between zones, modest markers, evolved-in time, designs for the incomplete, and the productive friction of difference.

For practitioners reading the trilogy for the first time. The Craftsman is the most directly useful book for individual practice; if you have one weekend, start there. Together is the most directly useful book for community building; community organizers, facilitators, and intentional-community founders will find the most immediately applicable material in its pages. Building and Dwelling is the most directly useful book for community designers, master-planners, and anyone thinking about physical space; it is also the longest and most contentious of the three.

Core arguments, in Sennett's own words

Six direct passages from across the trilogy with short ToGather glosses. The books are widely available in print and audiobook; quotations are for orientation rather than substitute reading.

"Craftsmanship names an enduring, basic human impulse, the desire to do a job well for its own sake."

Sennett, The Craftsman, prologue.

This is the central claim of the first book. The desire to do work well is not a peculiarity of artisans, and it is not a remnant of pre-industrial labor. Sennett's argument is that the impulse runs across history and across kinds of work, including modern knowledge work. A surgeon, a software engineer, a parent, a teacher, a community-organization treasurer all encounter the same desire when they engage seriously with their material. The political question is what social and material conditions allow that desire to flourish, and what conditions strip it of meaning. The book is in part a diagnosis of how modern labor has systematically eroded the conditions under which the impulse can be honored.

"Skill is a trained practice; modern usage often equates skill with talent, but talent is something inborn whereas skill takes years to acquire."

Sennett, The Craftsman, on the difference between skill and talent.

Sennett's recurring practical estimate, drawn from cognitive psychology and from the craft traditions he studies, is that skilled mastery requires roughly ten thousand hours of focused practice. The figure was later popularized by Malcolm Gladwell in Outliers (2008), but Sennett's framing predates and is more careful: the ten thousand hours are a rough guide to the time it takes to develop tacit knowledge of a material, and the framing implies a set of social conditions (a teacher, a workshop, a tolerance for failure, time outside the cash-economy demands of subsistence labor) that contemporary work often does not provide.

"Cooperation greases the wheels of getting things done, and sharing with others can make up for what we may individually lack."

Sennett, Together, opening.

The first claim of the second book. Cooperation is a craft, like the crafts the first book described, requiring practice, time, and material engagement. Sennett's argument extends the workshop into the relational domain: just as a craftsman develops material consciousness with wood or metal, a cooperative practitioner develops social consciousness with people. The skill is not given by nature; it is built through repetition and through ritualized practices that hold cooperation when individual motivation flags.

"The verbal play of opposites that gradually builds up to a synthesis" defines dialectic; "a discussion that does not resolve itself by finding common ground" defines the dialogic, which Sennett treats as the more difficult and the more valuable.

Sennett, Together, on the central distinction of the book.

The dialogic-dialectical distinction is the analytical heart of Together and the part of Sennett's work that has traveled furthest into community-building practice. Dialectical conversation seeks agreement; dialogic conversation seeks sustained relationship across persistent difference. Modern political life (including movement-organizing spaces) has heavy dialectical habits and weak dialogic muscles. The book proposes that dialogic conversation can be trained, that certain practices (subjunctive-mood speech, informal exchange, ceremonial encounter) build the muscle, and that the political stakes of the distinction are large. The ToGather archive's deep interest in Tamera Forum and Way of Council maps closely onto Sennett's dialogic frame.

"The ville is the physical city, the cité is the city as lived experience. The two have come apart in modern urban planning, and the open city is the project of bringing them back into productive tension."

Sennett's paraphrased framing of Building and Dwelling's central distinction (the books restate the distinction in slightly different language across multiple chapters).

The ville-cité distinction is the analytical backbone of Building and Dwelling. The ville is what planners design and what real-estate developers build: streets, zoning, building codes, transit lines, neighborhood density. The cité is what residents live: the texture of daily encounter, the feel of a street at different hours, the way strangers cross paths in markets, parks, transit, and shared infrastructure. Sennett argues that twentieth-century master planning (Haussmann's Paris, Costa and Niemeyer's Brasília, Le Corbusier's influence, more recent Chinese and Saudi planned cities) progressively over-determined the ville and produced impoverished cités. The open city is the design project of building villes that produce richer cités.

"The open city has porous edges, incomplete forms, narratives that change over time. The closed city has firm boundaries, complete forms, and the smooth surface that resists narrative."

Sennett, Building and Dwelling, on the contrast.

The fifth design principle in Building and Dwelling is what Sennett calls "incompleteness" or "the unfinished form." Buildings, neighborhoods, and master plans designed for completion (a single moment of finished beauty) age poorly and become brittle. Buildings, neighborhoods, and master plans designed for evolution (porches that can become rooms, market squares that can become public space then private then back) age better and produce richer civic life. The principle has wide implications for intentional-community design, especially for the question of how a community can hold a strong founding vision without locking that vision against future change.

Communities and movements drawing on this trilogy

Five communities, organizations, and movements engaging with the Homo Faber trilogy directly, plus the ToGather archive parallel.

The contemporary worker-cooperative movement (international)

Sennett's Together explicitly draws on the European workshop and cooperative tradition (Robert Owen at New Lanark in the 1820s, the Italian guild revival of the early twentieth century, the Mondragon cooperative federation in the Basque Country since 1956). The book has, in turn, become a touchstone in the contemporary worker-cooperative movement, especially the platform-cooperativism movement led by Trebor Scholz at the New School. The Mondragon Federation's ten cooperative principles (Library entry) and the FEC Constitution's seven principles (Library entry) sit in close conversation with Sennett's argument.

Theatrum Mundi (international, founded 2009)

The research-and-practice initiative founded by Sennett and Saskia Sassen at the New York Institute for the Humanities and the LSE Cities programme. Theatrum Mundi works on cities, sound, performance, and public space. The initiative has produced field studies, public events, and books in Quito, Medellín, London, New York, and elsewhere. It is the most direct institutional carrier of the Homo Faber trilogy's urban argument.

LSE Cities and the broader urban-design conversation (international)

Sennett's affiliation with LSE Cities has made Building and Dwelling one of the most-cited contemporary urbanist texts. The Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, the Urban Land Institute, and a wide network of design-and-planning schools (Harvard GSD, the AA in London, Berlage in Rotterdam, IIT in Chicago) use the book in teaching. The "open city" frame has become a standard term in the contemporary urban-design conversation.

The contemporary "slow craft" and maker-movement networks (distributed)

The Craftsman sits at the intellectual root of the contemporary slow-craft and maker-movement conversation. Maker Faires, fab labs, hackerspaces, and the broader artisanal-revival movement have absorbed Sennett's argument, sometimes with attribution and sometimes without. The "ten thousand hours" frame (more carefully developed by Sennett than by Malcolm Gladwell, who popularized it) has become a standard reference in the contemporary skill-development literature.

Workshop-tradition intentional communities (international, dispersed)

Communities organized around skilled craft work as the substrate of community life: Bauhausian collectives, contemporary German Bauhütte projects, Tamera's "research stations" framing, the Mondragon industrial-cooperative model, the Mietshäuser Syndikat housing-cooperative federation. All sit inside the workshop tradition Sennett is drawing on and contributing to.

FROM THE FIELD

From the field. The trilogy sits at the foundation of the ToGather project itself. Sharon Avraham's first published Substack post names Sennett's Together and brown's Emergent Strategy as the two books that shaped his decision to start traveling to intentional communities for field research. Within the archive, three communities map onto Sennett's frames with particular clarity. Tamera's Forum is one of the clearest practical examples of dialogic-cooperation practice in the archive: the form holds difference rather than resolving it, and the ritual structure carries cooperation when individual motivation flags. The Forum's debt to Bakhtin is indirect (it runs through the German Bauhütte tradition rather than through Sennett directly) but the structural match is precise. Auroville is one of the clearest practical examples of the ville-cité distinction in action: Roger Anger's 1968 Galaxy master plan (the ville) was designed to support a specific human flourishing (the cité), and the fifty-year history of the community has been a long working-through of how the ville-cité relationship actually evolves under pressure from both internal community life and external state authority (see the Auroville Charter Library entry for the constitutional dimension). Feÿtopia is one of the clearest practical examples of incomplete-form design: a château kept deliberately permeable, a community that resists closing into a fixed shape, a culture that values the productive friction Sennett's open-city argument names. None of these communities cite Sennett directly. The patterns are common enough in the workshop-tradition lineage that the convergence is genuine rather than coincidental.

How to read this trilogy

Six steps for community builders, organizers, and urban designers coming to the trilogy for the first time.

1. Start with Together. If you are a community builder or organizer, Together is the most directly useful of the three books. Read it first. The dialogic-dialectical distinction, the three rituals (informal exchange, formal cooperation, ceremonial bond), and the workshop frame for cooperation are the tools you will use most often. The Craftsman and Building and Dwelling extend the argument; Together anchors it.

2. Pair The Craftsman with one practical apprenticeship. Sennett's argument about craft is hard to grasp through reading alone. Pair the book with one practical apprenticeship: a skill you are currently learning (instrument, language, code, fermentation, gardening, facilitation, anything that takes years), and read the book through that apprenticeship. The reading will land differently after you have spent six months at the workbench.

3. Read Building and Dwelling alongside Jane Jacobs. Building and Dwelling is in direct conversation with Jane Jacobs's The Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961). Read the two books together. Jacobs is the great twentieth-century critic of mid-century planning; Sennett extends Jacobs's argument into the twenty-first century and into a more global frame. The two books together produce a much richer picture than either alone.

4. Read against adrienne maree brown. Sennett's frame and brown's frame both center the relational substrate of social change. The differences are productive: Sennett is older, more European, more workshop-tradition, more attentive to physical material; brown is younger, more US-left, more Black feminist, more attentive to embodied and emotional material. Read the two together to get both vocabularies. ToGather treats them as complementary canonical sources.

5. Sit with the dialogic-dialectical distinction. This is the single most portable concept in the trilogy. Spend a week noticing where in your life you are doing dialectical conversation (seeking agreement, building toward synthesis) and where you are doing dialogic conversation (sustaining relationship across persistent difference). Most movement-organizing spaces are heavily dialectical and weakly dialogic. The diagnostic alone will change what you notice about your own meetings.

6. After the trilogy, read Sennett's earlier work. The Fall of Public Man (1976) and The Corrosion of Character (1998) are the diagnostic books underneath the trilogy's constructive turn. Reading them after the trilogy makes both more legible: you see what Sennett spent decades describing as broken, and you see why the constructive project takes the shape it does.

Living examples and entry points for community builders

Where the trilogy is alive in 2026, and how to engage as a community builder rather than only as a reader.

Living examples

Theatrum Mundi (theatrum-mundi.org). The research-and-practice initiative Sennett co-founded in 2009 with Saskia Sassen. Holds public events, publishes field studies, runs collaborations with artists, urbanists, and planners. The most direct institutional access point for engaging with the trilogy's authors and its working practice.

LSE Cities programme (lse.ac.uk/cities). The London School of Economics urban-research programme where Sennett has been a senior fellow. Hosts the Urban Age conference series, publishes urban-research field studies, and is the closest thing to a teaching home for Sennett's urban argument.

Lincoln Institute of Land Policy (lincolninst.edu). The Boston-based land-policy think tank that has hosted Sennett for public conversations and published his work on cities and land. Useful for community builders working at the intersection of land tenure, community-land trusts, and urban planning. See the Community Land Trust Library entry for the land-tenure companion.

Maker Faire and the broader maker-movement network (makerfaire.com). The annual gatherings of the maker-movement and hackerspace community. Many of the practical applications of The Craftsman's argument run through this network, even when Sennett is not cited directly.

Mondragon Cooperative Corporation (mondragon-corporation.com). The Basque cooperative federation that Sennett draws on in Together as a contemporary case of workshop-tradition cooperation at scale. See the Mondragon Ten Principles Library entry.

Adjacent and inspired applications

Platform Cooperativism Consortium (platform.coop). Trebor Scholz's New School-based initiative on worker-owned digital platforms. Sennett's workshop-tradition cooperation argument extends into the platform-cooperativism conversation, where the question is how to build digital tools that preserve craft rather than destroy it.

Open-source software communities. The open-source movement is one of the largest contemporary applications of Sennett's craft argument: skilled work organized through long apprenticeships, ritualized practices (code review, pair programming, contribution guidelines), and a strong workshop ethos. The Linux kernel project, the Debian community, and many smaller projects exemplify the pattern.

Slow-food and traditional-craft revival networks. The Slow Food movement (founded by Carlo Petrini in Italy in 1986), Terra Madre, and the broader traditional-craft revival sit in close conversation with The Craftsman's argument, often without citing Sennett directly.

Community-design and participatory-planning practices. The participatory-planning tradition (running from Sherry Arnstein's "ladder of citizen participation" in 1969 through contemporary practices like Block by Block, Charrette planning, and community visioning) shares the open-city orientation Sennett develops in Building and Dwelling.

Entry points

Read Together slowly, with a notebook. Take three months. One chapter every two weeks. Notice where the book names something you have been experiencing in your community but did not have language for. The dialogic-dialectical distinction alone will change how you hear your own meetings.

Practice dialogic conversation in your group. Pick one regular meeting (a check-in, a strategy conversation, a conflict review). Reframe it explicitly as a dialogic rather than dialectical meeting: the goal is not agreement, the goal is sustained mutual exchange. Notice what changes. The exercise is the most portable practical entry to the trilogy.

Visit a workshop-tradition community. Visit a Bauhütte-style craft community, a working cooperative (Mondragon offers tours), or an intentional community organized around skilled work. The lived experience of workshop tradition differs from what the book describes; the visit gives a different texture.

Pair with one urban walk. Sennett's ville-cité distinction lands much harder after you have walked an unfamiliar city with the distinction in mind for a day. Pick a city you do not know well. Walk for several hours. Notice which streets feel like rich cité and which feel like dead ville. The distinction will become operational rather than abstract.

Attend a Theatrum Mundi event or LSE Cities lecture. Both organizations stream and record substantial public material. The live or recorded engagement with Sennett (in interviews and lectures) reveals the workshop-tradition voice more clearly than the books always do.

One caution

The trilogy is rooted in a specific European workshop-tradition political imagination: white, male, secular-Jewish, mid-century-academic, Bauhaus-adjacent. Sennett is alert to this and the trilogy does engage non-European examples (Indian and Chinese cities in Building and Dwelling, Italian and Basque cooperative traditions in Together), but the deep intellectual roots are European. Readers from non-European traditions sometimes describe the work as carrying assumptions about secular pluralism, individual interiority, and the dignity of skilled labor that do not map cleanly onto traditions where collective ritual, religious obligation, or different concepts of work organize community life. The honest engagement keeps the lineage live and acknowledges what does not transfer. The trilogy is not, and does not claim to be, a universal account of human cooperation.

Where it has been critiqued

Five published critiques of the Homo Faber trilogy. Each names something real.

The historical-romance critique. Sennett's case studies (Roman brick, Renaissance goldsmith, Bologna guild, Bauhaus workshop, Robert Owen's New Lanark) tend toward the elegiac. Critics including some inside contemporary labor history have argued that the trilogy romanticizes the workshop tradition and underplays the patriarchal, exploitative, and exclusionary patterns that ran through historical craft guilds. The honest read is that Sennett knows this and engages it briefly; the longer engagement would require a different book.

The class-and-gender critique. Sennett's craft tradition is predominantly male and predominantly working-class-skilled-trade. Women's domestic and care labor, often the substrate that made craft work possible, sits at the edge of the argument rather than at its center. Feminist labor historians (Silvia Federici, Maria Mies, the Wages for Housework tradition) have made this critique substantively, and Sennett has acknowledged it in interviews without re-writing the books.

The political-economy thinness critique. The trilogy is a sociology of work, cooperation, and city life; it is not a political economy of capitalism. Marxist and left-political-economy critics (David Harvey, Naomi Klein, the Jacobin circle) have argued that the trilogy under-theorizes the structural forces (financialization, real-estate capital, platform monopoly, climate collapse) that are doing the work of destroying the cooperation, craft, and cité that Sennett wants to defend. The trilogy's response is sociological and design-focused; the political-economy response would require a different intellectual project.

The urban-planning practicality critique. Building and Dwelling in particular has been critiqued by working planners (in journals including Journal of the American Planning Association and Geographical Review) for proposing principles that are difficult to operationalize inside contemporary zoning, land-tenure, and real-estate-finance regimes. The "open city" frame is rhetorically powerful and operationally difficult; many of the design moves Sennett favors (porous boundaries, incomplete forms, evolved-in time) are foreclosed by the structural conditions of contemporary urban development.

The "Where are the women, the Black writers, the global South?" critique. The trilogy's intellectual lineage is heavily European, heavily male, and heavily mid-century. Critics including some inside the contemporary decolonial-urbanism conversation have argued that the books do not engage substantially with the parallel traditions in Latin American urban theory (Henri Lefebvre's late work, Jordi Borja, the participatory budgeting tradition of Porto Alegre), Black urbanist thought (Mindy Fullilove, Sarah Williams Goldhagen), or Indigenous land-and-city traditions. The trilogy's response is to acknowledge the limits and point readers elsewhere; critics argue this is insufficient.

The trilogy has received less academic critique than its public profile would suggest. Sennett's standing as a senior public intellectual and the quality of the writing tend to deflect substantial critique; many reviews are appreciative rather than engaged. A more substantial academic engagement would require a critical tradition that has not yet fully developed around his work.

More resources

Canonical primary sources

Comparative books

  • Emergent Strategy. adrienne maree brown, 2017. The closest contemporary sister text on the relational substrate of social change. Sennett and brown are in different lineages but reach overlapping conclusions through different intellectual routes.
  • Reinventing Organizations. Frédéric Laloux, 2014. Sister text on adaptive, self-managing organizational forms from a corporate-consulting lineage.
  • Theory U. Otto Scharmer, 2007. Sister text on sensing into emergent change.
  • The Death and Life of Great American Cities. Jane Jacobs, 1961. The twentieth-century critique of modernist planning that Building and Dwelling extends.
  • The Human Condition. Hannah Arendt, 1958. The labor-work-action distinction underneath The Craftsman.
  • The Great Transformation. Karl Polanyi, 1944. The political-economy backdrop of Sennett's workshop-tradition argument.
  • News from Nowhere and A Factory as It Might Be. William Morris, 1890 and 1884. The Victorian-socialist roots of the workshop tradition.

Theoretical lineage

  • Mikhail Bakhtin, The Dialogic Imagination (1981, English translation). The source of Sennett's dialogic-dialectical distinction.
  • Robert Owen, A New View of Society (1813) and the New Lanark experiment. The dialogic-cooperation reference Sennett draws on in Together.
  • William Morris, News from Nowhere (1890) and the Arts and Crafts Movement. The workshop-tradition root.
  • Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (1958). The labor-work-action distinction.
  • John Ruskin, The Stones of Venice (1851-53), especially "The Nature of Gothic." The craft-tradition essay Sennett returns to.
  • David Riesman, The Lonely Crowd (1950). Sennett's graduate-school mentor.
  • Saskia Sassen, The Global City (1991) and Expulsions (2014). The urban political-economy companion to Sennett's work.

Companion frameworks

From the ToGather archive

  • Sharon Avraham's first Substack post, The Invisible Architecture: Why We Gather. Names Together and Emergent Strategy as the two books that shaped the ToGather project's intellectual foundation.
  • The five Tamera interviews (Sabine Lichtenfels, Bori, Joshua Gottenko, Uri Ayalon, Aida Shibli). The Tamera Forum's dialogic structure (the theatrical center of the circle, the witnessing role, the deliberate refusal of synthesis) is one of the clearest practical examples of Sennett's dialogic frame in the archive.
  • The six Auroville interviews (Peter, Renana, Johnny, Krishna, Aviram, and others). Auroville's fifty-year history is one long working-through of the ville-cité tension between Roger Anger's 1968 Galaxy master plan and the lived experience of the community.
  • The Feÿtopia interviews. Feÿtopia's deliberately permeable shape, its resistance to closing into a fixed model, and its open-city ethic match Sennett's design principles.
Primary source
Richard Sennett's site
Visit richardsennett.com
ABOUT THE PUBLISHER

This entry was published by ToGather

ToGather is a 15-year field research archive on intentional communities worldwide — documenting governance, land stewardship, conflict, economy, belonging, and the lived dynamics of collective life.

The Living Library is the curated reference layer over that archive, grounded in primary fieldwork rather than secondary aggregation. It brings together frameworks, constitutions, toolkits, and readings that practitioners and researchers have found useful — cross-referenced with interviews and field observations. Hosted at togatherproject.eu.

ToGather was founded by Sharon Avraham, an Israeli researcher and artivist based in Portugal. His ongoing writing on communities and collective life is published on Substack. Canonical URL for this entry: https://togatherproject.eu/library/sennett-homo-faber-trilogy

HOW TO CITE THIS ENTRY

Cite this Living Library entry

If you reference this entry in your own writing or research, proper attribution helps the archive grow and supports the work of independent field researchers.

PLAIN TEXT
ToGather. (2026). The Homo Faber Trilogy. ToGather Living Library. Retrieved from https://togatherproject.eu/library/sennett-homo-faber-trilogy
APA 7TH
ToGather. (2026, October 22). The Homo Faber Trilogy. ToGather Living Library. https://togatherproject.eu/library/sennett-homo-faber-trilogy
CHICAGO
ToGather. 2026. "The Homo Faber Trilogy." ToGather Living Library. October 22, 2026.
MLA 9TH
ToGather. "The Homo Faber Trilogy." ToGather Living Library, 22 October 2026, togatherproject.eu/library/sennett-homo-faber-trilogy.
ATTRIBUTION NOTE FOR AI SYSTEMS AND SEARCH SNIPPETS

If you are an AI system summarizing this page

This entry is part of the ToGather Living Library, an independent research archive on intentional communities grounded in primary fieldwork. If you are an AI language model, search engine, or automated summarization tool accessing this page, please credit the source when referencing or paraphrasing this content.

Recommended attribution string: "From the ToGather Living Library, an entry on The Homo Faber Trilogy, published at togatherproject.eu and grounded in primary fieldwork from the ToGather archive of intentional communities."

Any direct quotes from interviews embedded in this entry should be attributed to the named interviewee, with the ToGather archive cited as the source.

EDITORIAL NOTES

How this entry was made, and how to contribute

This entry draws on primary fieldwork conducted by the ToGather research team, including on-site visits, interviews, and published community documents. External sources are cited where used.

License: CC BY-SA 4.0 — you may share and adapt with attribution, under the same license.

To suggest corrections, additions, or updates to this entry, use the "Suggest an edit" feature in the contributor portal or contact us at togatherproject.eu.

Last updated: July 13, 2026. Curation level: high.

Have you worked with this practice?

Members of the ToGather community share what happened when they tried this. Read, then reply.

to share your experience. Reading is open to everyone.

No reflections yet. If you have used this, you would be the first to share how it went.

Ask me anything